Search Reviews

Please note that search is case-sensitive. Searching for author "chesterton" will NOT find items by G.K. Chesterton.

The Rose and Crown

Book cover: 'The Rose and Crown'
Author(s): 
Meriol Trevor
Grade / Age level: 
Copyright: 
1999
Review: 

This fourth and final book in the Letzenstein Chronicles tells of young Toby who was found - lost and orphaned - by the eccentric and mysterious Raphael le Marre in a previous book. Raphael ("Raf") seems appropriately named after one of the archangels as he has a way of coming to the rescue of children in trouble and has in fact adopted (along with his wife) some 20 children of his own. In this story Raf brings Toby back to his relatives in London in order to decide his future. Toby has no interest in staying with anyone but Raf. Toby's maternal grandfather is kind, but unable to support him financially, while a rich and arrogant uncle from his father's side insists on adopting him. Meanwhile, adventures befall everyone involved and Raf (who is Catholic) shares some interesting thoughts about Protestant England even while working with and being helped by a kind Anglican minister. The story is charming and a fairly easy read for early to mid grade school or as a family read-aloud. There are some elements of the story which might be troubling or confusing for young children sensitive to issues relating to adoption or having a step-parent.

Publisher: 
Bethlehem Books
Binding: 
Sewn Softcover
Number of pages: 
199 pages
Review Date: 
2-28-2000
Reviewed by: 
TitleSort: 
Rose and Crown

The Sacrament of Confirmation for Confirmation Candidates

Author(s): 
the Dominicans in Bologna, Italy
the Institute of St. Clement I
Subject(s): 
Grade / Age level: 
Copyright: 
2006
Review: 

The Sacrament of Confirmation for Confirmation Candidates is a concise, thorough, and faithful resource for confirmation preparation.

The book is divided into three parts. The first section covers what the sacrament of Confirmation is and the rite and its effects, providing a basic understanding of the sacrament in question-and-answer form. The second section breaks down the creed as it explains the truths of the Catholic faith. This also is presented in question and answer form. The third section discusses witnesses (or martyrs) of the Faith and highlights the lives of a few, selected saints.

A sample Q&A from Part I:

Q. When did Jesus institute the sacrament?

A. After having promised this sacrament, Jesus instituted Confirmation on the day of Pentecost when He sent the Holy Spirit on the Apostles and Mary gathered in the Cenacle. The Apostles immediately began to preach and make known their faith in Jesus Christ, crucified and risen.

Other questions in Part I include, “How is the sacrament of Confirmation conferred?", "What is chrism?" and "What are the names of the seven gifts of the Holy Spirit?"

I particularly like the way they break down the Creed into question and answer form in Part II, giving depth and meaning to it as they explain many truths of our Faith. The questions include many which are often asked of Catholics, making this a helpful apolgetics tool. For example:

Is faith the only way to know that God exists?
How can our reason prove the existence of God?
Why do we say that God is Father?
What does the expression ‘Mother of God’ mean in reference to the Virgin Mary?

The spotlight on a few selected saints in Part III also serves as a starting point for candidates to pick their confirmation names, inspired by the holiness of the saints’ lives.

Almost every page includes a colorful illustration, which brings to life the points of the text. One of the best examples of this is when the text discusses the seven gifts of the Holy Spirit. We see a galley ship with the seven gifts of the Holy Spirit written on the sails and seven virtues of the Holy Spirit written on the oars. Underneath the picture we read,

The virtues are like oars which propel the boat forward with great effort; the gifts of the Spirit are like sails which push the boat forward without any effort on the part of the rowers.

While the illustrations are not outstanding, they are quaint and colorful.

The logical presentation of the facts written in easy to understand language makes this book accessible for any age Confirmation candidate. The questions go beyond rote memorization by helping the candidate to reflect on the truths of the faith.

This book could be used in either a classroom or homeschool setting. When the time comes, I plan to use this with my children who are preparing for Confirmation.

Publisher: 
New Hope Publications

My one and only quibble with the text is the use of the expression “adult, mature Christians” when describing Confirmation. “Confirmation makes us perfect Christians, that is adult, mature Christians.” I think this terminology can lead to misunderstanding about this sacrament. The text does go on to explain that “Confirmation, therefore, by its very nature, ought to be celebrated before the Eucharist, that is, before First Communion. However, for serious pastoral reasons, in many countries it is celebrated later in order to assure adolescents a longer religious formation.”

I think the expression “adult, mature Christians” creates confusion because people think the child needs to choose this sacrament as a sign of adulthood, instead of spiritual maturity. Also, in the Eastern Rites the child does not even need to be the age of reason to receive Confirmation and is usually an infant.

Question #5 does address this issue. “Why do we say that Confirmation is the sacrament of adulthood? We do not say this because the sacrament must necessarily be received by adults, but because it enables us to bear witness to and defend the faith to others. This is proper to adulthood, though spiritual adulthood does not necessarily coincide with bodily age.”

The Catechism of the Catholic Church #1308 also clarifies this point. “Although Confirmation is sometimes called the ‘sacrament of Christian maturity,’ we must not confuse adult faith with the adult age of natural growth. . .”

Binding: 
Softcover
Perspective: 
Catholic
Number of pages: 
107 pages
Review Date: 
11-27-2007
Reviewed by: 
TitleSort: 
Sacrament of Confirmation for Confirmation Candidates

The Salamander Room

Author(s): 
Anne Mazer
Subject(s): 
Illustrator(s): 
Steve Johnson
Lou Fancher
Grade / Age level: 
Resource Type: 
Copyright: 
1991
Review: 

The Salamander Room is a beautifully illustrated picture book that is sure to captivate the nature-loving child. Brian finds a salamander and asks his mother to keep him as a pet. Rather than saying "no" his mother asks leading questions as to where the salamander will sleep, what he will eat, where he will play and if he'll be lonely.

Eager to keep his new pet, but also desiring to give him a happy home, Brian reassures his mother that he will bring moss into his room, wet leaves, boulders and insects to make the salamander happy.

Brian's mother continues to question, and Brian continues to imagine bringing the out of doors--in. He says he will bring trees into his room and birds... and by the end, Brian has lifted the roof off his room in order to let in the sun and rain. In fact, so much of the salamander's home has found its way into Brian's room that the only thing recognizable about Brian's room is Brian's bed where he hopes to sleep under the stars beside his new pet salamander.

Publisher: 
Dragonfly Books
Binding: 
Softcover
Number of pages: 
12 pages
Review Date: 
8-16-2007
Reviewed by: 
TitleSort: 
Salamander Room

The Sally Series

Away Goes Sally, Five Bushel Farm, The Fair American, The White Horse, The Wonderful Day
Author(s): 
Elizabeth Coatsworth
Subject(s): 
Illustrator(s): 
Helen Sewell
Grade / Age level: 
Review: 

The Sally Books by Elizabeth Coatsworth
Away Goes Sally (pgs 117), Five Bushel Farm (pgs 142), The Fair American (pgs 134), The White Horse (pgs 168), The Wonderful Day (pgs 139)

In our house, we always have at least two read-alouds going: one that I read to the kids during the day and the other in the evening that Dad reads to the kids before bed. We do this year-round, so even in the summer-time we’re doing our read-alouds. My kids particularly like a series of books read to them – either books by the same author, books about the same characters or books about the same theme.

Just as we finished our “regular” school year this year, we received the Sally series by Elizabeth Coatsworth. We liked this series so much, we have talked Dad into reading them again at night later this summer!

Sally, an indomitable orphan growing up in the state of Maine during the 1790s with aunts and uncles, is a wonderfully drawn character whose “Pollyanna” attitude toward life never seems fake, but rather that of a girl who has a warm heart, living in a loving family. These books span just a few years but include bits of information about the French Revolution and the Barbary pirates marauding the Mediterranean. We learned so much not only about rural life “back then” but these books also set us off on rabbit trails to learn about the French Revolution, the French-Indian Wars, and the African pirates and the despotism of the sultans of the era.

The first book, Away Goes Sally, sets the stage for the other books. It’s 1790 and 10-year-old Sally lives with her aunts: Nannie (the eldest and thus, in charge and very domineering), Esther (the youngest), Deborah (the quiet, shy, amenable aunt). Two uncles are also in the house: Joseph (head of the household) and Eben (lazy but lovable). The five adults, all siblings, work hard to give Sally a life full of love and faith in Massachusetts. A cousin invites the family to immigrate to the “wilds of Maine” where land is abundant and fertile. Exactly how Uncle Joseph gets Aunt Nannie to move is the plot – and did we wish we were Sally along for the ride!

Five Bushel Farm starts out in Maine with Sally’s relatives, the Hallets. Cousin Ephraim has found an orphan who needs love and brings him into his house, which is anything but loving. Once Sally and her aunts and uncles get settled in Maine, they bring the orphan to their loving home as one of the aunts goes off to marry. Friendly Native Americans and building a farm are described in great detail; finding the perfect spot for their farm, and the reason behind the name of the book, create a picture of putting down roots in more ways than one.

The French Revolution comes into play in the third book, The Fair American. Pierre, the son of a courtier, must flee his family estate just before villagers, fired by revolutionary fever, set it ablaze. Escape from France means boarding a ship where we finally re-meet Sally and Andrew. I loved the way Coatsworth linked the French Revolution to peace-filled America.

A year after the adventures aboard the Fair American, Sally and Andrew convince Aunt Nannie to allow Sally to set sail again, this time for Italy. The White Horse opens with Sally and Andrew sailing into the Mediterranean on a seemingly easy voyage. An easy voyage until the ship is attacked by pirates, the captives taken to Morocco, and imprisoned in a sultan’s palace. How the characters co-exist with the Muslims in a sultan’s palace is the point of the novel. Sally’s love of life helps all around in these trying times and the conclusion is exciting in this, the longest book of the series.

The series ends with The Wonderful Day. Sally is about 16 or so and finding it hard to be the “lady” Aunt Nannie would like her to be. Still full of love and life, Sally starts the day with great optimism which quickly turns to dismay when Sally discovers that her Uncle Joseph is in financial trouble. “Saving the day” is Sally’s job as the day and troubles compound. This book brings up an interesting idea of trust, honesty and how easy it could be to dupe those who believe everyone is as honest as they are.

This series is suitable for independent readers about age 8 and up. It proved a great read-aloud series for my 6 and 10 year old boys and my 9 year old daughter. We all loved the books and they fit well with our study of American history this year, reinforcing what we learned.

Publisher: 
Bethlehem Books
Series: 
The Sally Books
Binding: 
Paperback
Review Date: 
6-18-2009
Reviewed by: 
TitleSort: 
Sally Series

The Saving Name of God the Son

Author(s): 
Jean Ann Sharpe
Subject(s): 
Grade / Age level: 
Resource Type: 
Copyright: 
2009
Review: 

Bethlehem Books has just released the first in a set of three new board books on the Blessed Trinity. This first one is about God the Son and it's gorgeous! Each page has a lovely painting by early Renaissance artist Fra Angelico, illustrating a scene from the Life of Christ. The paintings are accompanied by short, rich text that speaks of who Jesus is. It's a very quick read, just a few lines per page, but thoughtfully put together and one that can be reflected on over and over again.

The series description has some interesting things to say about the intentions of the publisher for this series:

The Teaching the Language of the Faith Series presents read-aloud books that foster reflective interaction between the child listener and the adult reader. Thoughtful religious art is chosen to interrelate with words pertinent to faith understanding. Each aspect extends the meaning of the other. As children gain a familiarity with words and images relevant to Christian truth, they are prepared to enter more fully and more personally into the beauty and mystery of the Christian faith.

An "Art and Text References" segment in back includes references to the Bible and the Catechism of the Catholic Church for each painting. These would be great for further discussion and family study.

Kudos to Bethlehem Books for recognizing the great capacity of very young children for beauty and mystery!

Note: Bethlehem Books has a free PDF page of suggestions for how to use this book with your child.

Publisher: 
Bethlehem Books
Binding: 
Other
Perspective: 
Catholic
Number of pages: 
22 pages
Review Date: 
9-28-2009
Reviewed by: 
TitleSort: 
Saving Name of God the Son

The Scarlet and the Black

Subject(s): 
Resource Type: 
Copyright: 
1983
Review: 

Christopher Plummer and Gregory Peck play arch-enemies in this story of a remarkable Irish Monsignor living in the Vatican who runs a network of safehouses for Jews, escaped POWs and others seeking refuge in Nazi-occupied Rome. Monsignor O'Flaherty (Gregory Peck) boldly collects funds for his work at high-profile parties and events and narrowly escapes capture at every turn. As Nazi Commandant Hoffer (Christopher Plummer) realizes the scope of O'Flaherty's threat to Nazi purposes, the good Monsignor's danger increases. Virtually a prisoner in the Vatican, he invents daring disguises in order to keep his network running and often remove refugees to safety just moments before the Nazis show up for an arrest attempt. This is a great movie - true story, compelling plot, great cast, etc. My only uncertainty is whether Sir John Gielgud's portrayal of Pope Pius XII is fair (he comes across as rather wimpy), but this is a rather minor part of the movie.

Publisher: 
Artisan/Fox Video
Additional notes: 

156 min, Color - now available on VHS and DVD

Review Date: 
7-21-03
Reviewed by: 
TitleSort: 
Scarlet and the Black

The Scarlet Pimpernel

Book cover: 'The Scarlet Pimpernel'
Author(s): 
Barroness Orczy
Subject(s): 
Copyright: 
1905
Review: 

This classic romance/mystery set in the French Revolution is the story of a wealthy British nobleman, Percy, with a daring and secret side of his life which he keeps hidden even from his wife - a beautiful French actress. Percy and some close friends have found a sport much more exciting, noble, and dangerous than the typical fox-hunting: that of rescuing French aristocrats from the raging mobs and guillotine of the French revolution. Fast-paced and suspenseful, the story is both enjoyable and enlightening as to the evils of the French Revolution contrasted with the nobility of those who tried to counter evil with good.

Publisher: 
Penguin Classics
Binding: 
Softcover
Number of pages: 
288 pages
Review Date: 
3-25-2000
Reviewed by: 
TitleSort: 
Scarlet Pimpernel

The Scarlet Pimpernel (BBC/A&E Series)

Book cover: 'The Scarlet Pimpernel'
Subject(s): 
Resource Type: 
Copyright: 
1998
Review: 

After thoroughly enjoying the BBC/A&E production of Pride and Prejudice, I was thrilled to see that they also had done the Scarlet Pimpernel, which is one of my favorite stories. Unfortunately, my expectations were completely shattered by this production which is really more of a television series loosely based on the books. It seems intended for those who enjoy rather steamy romance novels. While some of the original elements of the story and the truths regarding the evils of the French Revolution remain intact (and there are a few funny and creative scenes), there is little else to recommend this production - and many reasons not to bother. I haven't read all of the Pimpernel books, but there was very little reminiscent of the main book from which it takes its name (none of the principal characters even wore disguises!) and there is a lot of raunchy material that I found extremely difficult to tolerate (and I'm a relatively tolerant person when it comes to annoying parts in movies). The writers seem intent on creating heinous female villains and turning Marguerite St. Just into a more politically correct character. Chauvelin, to whom they attempt to give some "sex appeal", makes me nauseous. I found the scenes in Paris indicative of the disintegrating culture absolutely revolting, and these were not even treated as revolting by the production. Instead, for example, Sir Percy Blakeney makes a flippant joke about losing one's virginity when one of his companions is sensually undressed by a group of women at a party. Please, please, please, don't waste your money on this one like I did!

Publisher: 
BBC/A&E
Additional notes: 

approx. 300 min., Color

Review Date: 
6-24-03
Reviewed by: 
TitleSort: 
Scarlet Pimpernel (BBC/A&E Series)

The Scrambled States of America

The Whimsical, Mad-Dashing, Geography Game
Book cover: 'The Scrambled States of America: The Whimsical, Mad-Dashing, Geography Game'
Subject(s): 
Setting: 
Grade / Age level: 
Resource Type: 
Copyright: 
2002
Review: 

The Scrambled States of America is based on a book of the same name by Laurie Keller. It involves making geography fun for young children through a story in which the states get mixed up and need to be put back in order. You don't need to know the story to enjoy the game, however.

The games involves two decks of cards - a state deck and a "scramble" deck. Players bring states "home" by following instructions on the "scramble" deck. These instructions involve things like: the state's color, letters or words found in the nickname, states that border that state and how many syllables in the capital. There are two levels of play. For younger children, anyone with a state matching the instructions on the "scramble" deck gets to bring that state "home." Older children can play a fast-paced version in which the first one to find a qualifying state gets to bring it "home."

The illustrations are a little "goofy" (each state is drawn with a face on it), but we found that our four children capable of playing (in our case, ages 5 1/2 through 12) enjoyed the game very much at their appropriate levels. I think the children practice valuable skills - searching for states on their maps, identifying attributes and learning about syllables (to name just a few).

You know it's a good game when children and adults both enjoy playing it!!!

Publisher: 
Gamewright
Additional notes: 

Copyrights 2002-2005

For 2 to 4 players, ages 8 and up.

Two card decks with a simple 8 1/2 x 11 paper map for each player

Review Date: 
10-29-05
Reviewed by: 
TitleSort: 
Scrambled States of America

The Seashell on the Mountaintop

Author(s): 
Alan Cutler
Setting: 
Grade / Age level: 
Copyright: 
2003
Review: 

The Seashell on the Mountaintop is a very welcome biography of St. Neils Stenson, also known as Nicholas Steno and about 16 other variations. The good news is that, after years of neglect, this convert, this holy man, and this founder of the science of geology is being pulled from the edge of oblivion to be remembered for his true greatness. The title of the book refers to the presence of fossil shells in the mountain soils of Italy and , among other places, and the long effort to interpret such a curiosity. As a Dane, Neils had not grown up in the presence of fossils, but he went to Italy as an adult and joined the academy that had been Galileo's fellowship a generation earlier. Here he took an interest in everything around, including the hills of Tuscany and their shells.

The geology part is interesting because Steno's ideas were so far ahead of others' that those who were interested in figuring out the fossil puzzle read them for a hundred years before they were able to take the next step in building the science. During his own lifetime, Neils was famous for he was a seminal thinker on several topics, but by the time the geologists were able to build on his work, his extraordinary personality was almost forgotten although, even today, the principles expressing our basic understanding of sedimentation are still called Steno's laws.

Cutler's gives a striking account of the competing ideas about fossils in Stenson's days – late 17th century. Did shell forms naturally grow in the soil? And if so, did they grow with breakages and wormholes and all, just as if they'd been on the shore? Were they dropped by Noah's Flood? If so, how had they come so far inland; many thought that Noah's finding a live tree branch after the flood meant it could not have brought salt water all the way inland everywhere. Cutler presents all this material thoughtfully and in a manner respectful of the mental challenges of another age, so easy to underestimate.

Not only the shells interested Neils, but also the faith of Italy, and though welcomed by the Florentine academy as a Lutheran, he became a Catholic in time, then a priest, and finally a very holy bishop of a vast tract of Lutheran Europe, for whose salvation he relinquished his scientific investigations and then sacrificed his health.

This is a good introduction to the 17th century, to geology, and to a saint with a wonderful, Renaissance mind.

Publisher: 
Plume Publishing
Perspective: 
Catholic
Number of pages: 
240 pages
Review Date: 
12-26-06
Reviewed by: 
TitleSort: 
Seashell on the Mountaintop